Main Page | Report this Page
 
   
Science Forum Index  »  Physics - Electromagnetic Forum  »  Electric generator...
Page 1 of 1    
Author Message
Peter...
Posted: Mon Jun 23, 2008 2:25 pm
Guest
Hi! Can someone please help me? I understand the force in an electric
generator is F = B (q x v). Is the work done on the generator equal to
W = B(q x v) (vt), where vt is the distance the electrons in the wire
move because of the rotation of the rotor? If the angular velocity of
the rotor is doubled, does the work done on the generator increase
four times, because it would then be W = B (q x 2v) (2vt); thus the
energy produced by the generator also increases four times? Thank.
Please excuse me if I am saying dumb things. I may be missing
something. I am trying to learn. Thanks.
Don Kelly...
Posted: Tue Jun 24, 2008 12:33 am
Guest
----------------------------
"Peter" <Poakfield at (no spam) msn.com> wrote in message
news:346cd631-7159-497e-a7aa-834fda352c9b at (no spam) i76g2000hsf.googlegroups.com...
Quote:
Hi! Can someone please help me? I understand the force in an electric
generator is F = B (q x v). Is the work done on the generator equal to
W = B(q x v) (vt), where vt is the distance the electrons in the wire
move because of the rotation of the rotor? If the angular velocity of
the rotor is doubled, does the work done on the generator increase
four times, because it would then be W = B (q x 2v) (2vt); thus the
energy produced by the generator also increases four times? Thank.
Please excuse me if I am saying dumb things. I may be missing
something. I am trying to learn. Thanks.

No. Note that force is q(v x B) not B (q x v) There is a difference. The x
is not a multiplication but a vector cross product. B and v are vectors
while q is a scalar (-ve for electrons).

It is easier to consider the case of a conductor of length l which is at
right angles to the field and to the motion- then this is simplified.
Then there is a force acting on the conductor of F=Bli where i is the
current (qv) and acting in a direction to oppose the motion - at right
angles to the current.
You can start from the same basis or use Faraday to determine the voltage
V=Blv
The power of the generator will be Vi which can be expressed as Fv and the
work in a given time will be the integral of this.
If you double the velocity, you will double the voltage but the current
will depend on what is connected to the terminals of the generator. If
open or short circuited, the work will be 0.
In between with some load there will be some power.

In the case of a fixed resistance load, doubling the speed, doubles the
voltage and so quadruples the power (and energy in a given time). You are
right with respect to that although your approach is not correct.

Don Kelly dhky at (no spam) shawcross.ca
remove the X to answer
Peter...
Posted: Tue Jun 24, 2008 4:36 am
Guest
On Jun 24, 1:33 am, "Don Kelly" <d... at (no spam) shaw.ca> wrote:
Quote:
----------------------------"Peter" <Poakfi... at (no spam) msn.com> wrote in message

news:346cd631-7159-497e-a7aa-834fda352c9b at (no spam) i76g2000hsf.googlegroups.com...

Hi! Can someone please help me? I understand the force in an electric
generator is F = B (q x v). Is the work done on the generator equal to
W = B(q x v) (vt), where vt is the distance the electrons in the wire
move because of the rotation of the rotor? If the angular velocity of
the rotor is doubled, does the work done on the generator increase
four times, because it would then be W = B (q x 2v) (2vt); thus the
energy produced by the generator also increases four times? Thank.
Please excuse me if I am saying dumb things. I may be missing
something. I am trying to learn. Thanks.

No. Note that force is q(v x B) not B (q x v) There is a difference. The x
is not a multiplication but a vector cross product. B and v are vectors
while q is a scalar (-ve for electrons).

It is easier to consider the case of a conductor of length l which is at
right angles to the field and to the motion- then this is simplified.
Then there is a force acting on the conductor of F=Bli where i is the
current (qv) and acting in a direction to oppose the motion - at right
angles to the current.
You can start from the same basis or use Faraday to determine the voltage
V=Blv
The power of the generator will be Vi  which can be expressed as Fv and the
work in a given time will be the integral of this.
If you double the velocity, you will double the  voltage but the current
will depend on  what is connected to the terminals of the  generator. If
open or short circuited, the work will be 0.
In between with some load there will be some power.

In the case of a fixed resistance load, doubling the speed, doubles the
voltage and so quadruples the power (and energy in a given time). You are
right with respect to that although  your approach is not correct.

Don Kelly d... at (no spam) shawcross.ca
remove the X to answer

Thank you. That helped a lot. Then, is it correct if I say the
instantaneous work done is W = q(v x B)(vt), where vt is the distance
and t is the time? (This is in analogy to W = force x distance.)
Don Kelly...
Posted: Wed Jun 25, 2008 12:34 am
Guest
..
----------------------------
"Peter" <Poakfield at (no spam) msn.com> wrote in message
news:c52fae08-023f-4eaa-bf82-1df097e63ae2 at (no spam) d1g2000hsg.googlegroups.com...
On Jun 24, 1:33 am, "Don Kelly" <d... at (no spam) shaw.ca> wrote:
Quote:
----------------------------"Peter" <Poakfi... at (no spam) msn.com> wrote in message

news:346cd631-7159-497e-a7aa-834fda352c9b at (no spam) i76g2000hsf.googlegroups.com...

Hi! Can someone please help me? I understand the force in an electric
generator is F = B (q x v). Is the work done on the generator equal to
W = B(q x v) (vt), where vt is the distance the electrons in the wire
move because of the rotation of the rotor? If the angular velocity of
the rotor is doubled, does the work done on the generator increase
four times, because it would then be W = B (q x 2v) (2vt); thus the
energy produced by the generator also increases four times? Thank.
Please excuse me if I am saying dumb things. I may be missing
something. I am trying to learn. Thanks.

No. Note that force is q(v x B) not B (q x v) There is a difference. The x
is not a multiplication but a vector cross product. B and v are vectors
while q is a scalar (-ve for electrons).

It is easier to consider the case of a conductor of length l which is at
right angles to the field and to the motion- then this is simplified.
Then there is a force acting on the conductor of F=Bli where i is the
current (qv) and acting in a direction to oppose the motion - at right
angles to the current.
You can start from the same basis or use Faraday to determine the voltage
V=Blv
The power of the generator will be Vi which can be expressed as Fv and the
work in a given time will be the integral of this.
If you double the velocity, you will double the voltage but the current
will depend on what is connected to the terminals of the generator. If
open or short circuited, the work will be 0.
In between with some load there will be some power.

In the case of a fixed resistance load, doubling the speed, doubles the
voltage and so quadruples the power (and energy in a given time). You are
right with respect to that although your approach is not correct.

Don Kelly d... at (no spam) shawcross.ca
remove the X to answer

Thank you. That helped a lot. Then, is it correct if I say the
instantaneous work done is W = q(v x B)(vt), where vt is the distance
and t is the time? (This is in analogy to W = force x distance.)
----------------------------------------
No. Note that the force is perpendicular to the velocity -not in the
direction of the velocity-not co-linear as in the mechanical analogy.


Don Kelly dhky at (no spam) shawcross.ca
remove the X to answer
Peter...
Posted: Wed Jun 25, 2008 1:34 am
Guest
On Jun 25, 1:34 am, "Don Kelly" <d... at (no spam) shaw.ca> wrote:
Quote:
.
----------------------------"Peter" <Poakfi... at (no spam) msn.com> wrote in message

news:c52fae08-023f-4eaa-bf82-1df097e63ae2 at (no spam) d1g2000hsg.googlegroups.com...
On Jun 24, 1:33 am, "Don Kelly" <d... at (no spam) shaw.ca> wrote:





----------------------------"Peter" <Poakfi... at (no spam) msn.com> wrote in message

news:346cd631-7159-497e-a7aa-834fda352c9b at (no spam) i76g2000hsf.googlegroups.com....

Hi! Can someone please help me? I understand the force in an electric
generator is F = B (q x v). Is the work done on the generator equal to
W = B(q x v) (vt), where vt is the distance the electrons in the wire
move because of the rotation of the rotor? If the angular velocity of
the rotor is doubled, does the work done on the generator increase
four times, because it would then be W = B (q x 2v) (2vt); thus the
energy produced by the generator also increases four times? Thank.
Please excuse me if I am saying dumb things. I may be missing
something. I am trying to learn. Thanks.

No. Note that force is q(v x B) not B (q x v) There is a difference. The x
is not a multiplication but a vector cross product. B and v are vectors
while q is a scalar (-ve for electrons).

It is easier to consider the case of a conductor of length l which is at
right angles to the field and to the motion- then this is simplified.
Then there is a force acting on the conductor of F=Bli where i is the
current (qv) and acting in a direction to oppose the motion - at right
angles to the current.
You can start from the same basis or use Faraday to determine the voltage
V=Blv
The power of the generator will be Vi which can be expressed as Fv and the
work in a given time will be the integral of this.
If you double the velocity, you will double the voltage but the current
will depend on what is connected to the terminals of the generator. If
open or short circuited, the work will be 0.
In between with some load there will be some power.

In the case of a fixed resistance load, doubling the speed, doubles the
voltage and so quadruples the power (and energy in a given time). You are
right with respect to that although your approach is not correct.

Don Kelly d... at (no spam) shawcross.ca
remove the X to answer

Thank you. That helped a lot. Then, is it correct if I say the
instantaneous work done is W = q(v x B)(vt), where vt is the distance
and t is the time? (This is in analogy to W = force x distance.)
----------------------------------------
No. Note that the force is perpendicular to the velocity -not in the
direction of the velocity-not co-linear as in the mechanical analogy.

Don Kelly d... at (no spam) shawcross.ca
remove the X to answer- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Thanks. Then, what would be the work done in terms of B, q, v, and t?
John C. Polasek...
Posted: Wed Jun 25, 2008 10:02 am
Guest
On Wed, 25 Jun 2008 04:34:22 -0700 (PDT), Peter <Poakfield at (no spam) msn.com>
wrote:

Quote:
On Jun 25, 1:34 am, "Don Kelly" <d... at (no spam) shaw.ca> wrote:
.
----------------------------"Peter" <Poakfi... at (no spam) msn.com> wrote in message

news:c52fae08-023f-4eaa-bf82-1df097e63ae2 at (no spam) d1g2000hsg.googlegroups.com...
On Jun 24, 1:33 am, "Don Kelly" <d... at (no spam) shaw.ca> wrote:





----------------------------"Peter" <Poakfi... at (no spam) msn.com> wrote in message

news:346cd631-7159-497e-a7aa-834fda352c9b at (no spam) i76g2000hsf.googlegroups.com...

Hi! Can someone please help me? I understand the force in an electric
generator is F = B (q x v). Is the work done on the generator equal to
W = B(q x v) (vt), where vt is the distance the electrons in the wire
move because of the rotation of the rotor? If the angular velocity of
the rotor is doubled, does the work done on the generator increase
four times, because it would then be W = B (q x 2v) (2vt); thus the
energy produced by the generator also increases four times? Thank.
Please excuse me if I am saying dumb things. I may be missing
something. I am trying to learn. Thanks.

No. Note that force is q(v x B) not B (q x v) There is a difference. The x
is not a multiplication but a vector cross product. B and v are vectors
while q is a scalar (-ve for electrons).

It is easier to consider the case of a conductor of length l which is at
right angles to the field and to the motion- then this is simplified.
Then there is a force acting on the conductor of F=Bli where i is the
current (qv) and acting in a direction to oppose the motion - at right
angles to the current.
You can start from the same basis or use Faraday to determine the voltage
V=Blv
The power of the generator will be Vi which can be expressed as Fv and the
work in a given time will be the integral of this.
If you double the velocity, you will double the voltage but the current
will depend on what is connected to the terminals of the generator. If
open or short circuited, the work will be 0.
In between with some load there will be some power.

In the case of a fixed resistance load, doubling the speed, doubles the
voltage and so quadruples the power (and energy in a given time). You are
right with respect to that although your approach is not correct.

Don Kelly d... at (no spam) shawcross.ca
remove the X to answer

Thank you. That helped a lot. Then, is it correct if I say the
instantaneous work done is W = q(v x B)(vt), where vt is the distance
and t is the time? (This is in analogy to W = force x distance.)
----------------------------------------
No. Note that the force is perpendicular to the velocity -not in the
direction of the velocity-not co-linear as in the mechanical analogy.

Don Kelly d... at (no spam) shawcross.ca
remove the X to answer- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Thanks. Then, what would be the work done in terms of B, q, v, and t?
Peter, you would do yourself a favor if you didn't try to coerce the

Lorentz force as an explanation of the dynamics of a motor or
generator. Lorentz force is no factor, if only because the force is
normal to the motion.
Secondly, q x v, charge times velocity is not a current; you would
need charge per unit length times velocity to make a current. And you
need to deal in currents.
Study up on Lentz' law and other elementary concepts; the Lorentz
force is in a separate exotic class.
John Polasek
 
Page 1 of 1       All times are GMT - 5 Hours
The time now is Fri Dec 05, 2008 9:52 am