Main Page | Report this Page
 
   
Science Forum Index  »  Medicine - Dentistry Forum  »  What exactly is a "custom abutment" for an implant...
Page 1 of 1    
Author Message
JimSocal...
Posted: Mon Jun 23, 2008 3:35 am
Guest
.... and when is it necessary to have one?
Richard...
Posted: Thu Jun 26, 2008 7:33 am
Guest
A custom abutment is a part that is machined out of a block of titanium
which fits into the implant and a crown is made over it. Some doctors or
laboratories use them for all of their cases, some use modified stock
abutments. I have never used them. For more info:
http://www.atlantiscomp.com/

JimSocal wrote:
> ... and when is it necessary to have one?
Mark & Steven Bornfeld...
Posted: Thu Jun 26, 2008 10:06 am
Guest
Richard wrote:
Quote:
A custom abutment is a part that is machined out of a block of titanium
which fits into the implant and a crown is made over it. Some doctors or
laboratories use them for all of their cases, some use modified stock
abutments. I have never used them. For more info:
http://www.atlantiscomp.com/

JimSocal wrote:
... and when is it necessary to have one?



This looks like an interesting technology, but most custom abutments
are not milled by a CAD-CAM technology--they are custom cast, usually
in gold alloy (there is a titanium understructure that screws into the
implant fixture.
They are generally used when the placement of the implant fixture is
such that it is not possible to place a functional, esthetic crown using
a stock (pre-made) abutment. Of course, occasionally fixtures are
placed such that it's impossible to put a crown or attachment in a good
clinical position. That's why collaboration between the surgeon and
restorative dentist is so important.

Steve

--
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
http://www.dentaltwins.com
Brooklyn, NY
718-258-5001
JimSocal...
Posted: Wed Jul 02, 2008 2:13 pm
Guest
On Thu, 26 Jun 2008 15:06:52 GMT, Mark & Steven Bornfeld
<bornfeldmung at (no spam) dentaltwins.com> wrote:

Quote:
Richard wrote:
A custom abutment is a part that is machined out of a block of titanium
which fits into the implant and a crown is made over it. Some doctors or
laboratories use them for all of their cases, some use modified stock
abutments. I have never used them. For more info:
http://www.atlantiscomp.com/

JimSocal wrote:
... and when is it necessary to have one?



This looks like an interesting technology, but most custom abutments
are not milled by a CAD-CAM technology--they are custom cast, usually
in gold alloy (there is a titanium understructure that screws into the
implant fixture.
They are generally used when the placement of the implant fixture is
such that it is not possible to place a functional, esthetic crown using
a stock (pre-made) abutment. Of course, occasionally fixtures are
placed such that it's impossible to put a crown or attachment in a good
clinical position. That's why collaboration between the surgeon and
restorative dentist is so important.

Steve

Thank you Richard and Dr. Bornfeld for your answers.

This is what my student dentist told me (I got an email back from her
after your replies; this work was done about a year ago):

"custom abutments are not required, stock abutments could have been
used, but in my experience results are better with custom abutments
especially when multiple implants are used as in your case. Some form
of abutment has to be used otherwise the PFM (crown) can not be
placed, since it is the connector between the implant screw and crown.

I'm not sure why your original treatment plan did not include the
custom abutments, it might have been that at the time of your original
treatment plan the University did not charge for abutments."
-------------------------------------------------------
By the way, if her last comment is the case, then I think the prices
on my treatment plan should be honored.

This is why I am asking the question:
I had a Treatment Plan for 4 implant crowns and it called for 6
implant crowns at $850 each. [2 had not yet been done at the time of
this bill). This is what I agreed to and I was never told anything
different was going to be done or that any expenses were being added.

So when I got my bill, I saw that I was charged $675 for the Implant
crowns, high noble - but also 4 x $650 for "Implant Custom Abutments".

So that is $2600 more than what I was told I'd be charged, and no one
dicussed this with me! (??!!)

(Granted, the PFM's were $175 less each so that offsets some of the
difference, but still that leaves a $1900 difference added.)

So I am in the process of contesting this on the grounds that I was
never told they would be needed.

Would it not be standard practice to tell a patient if an extra $2600
was going to be added to his bill? especially if he has a signed
treatment plan that does not call for custom abutments?

I think at the very least they should compromise with me and charge me
LESS for the custom abutments.

What do you think?

And maybe you can help me out here - if I paid $650 per crown and $675
per custom abutment (remember, this is at a dental school, so I should
get it cheaper - I had to endure many more appt's than necessary for
their lack of competence and many more hours in the chair for the same
reason plus they are learning on me), how much room is there for them
to discount this any further to allow for any money back due to their
having not told me about it?

I'm willing to compromise as I understand it may have just been an
oversight, but still I don't think it's right to expect a person to
pay $1900 more than their treatment plan called for without having
told them.

And finally, what would be an average ballpark price for custom
abutments per crown at a dental office?

Comments? Opinions?
Mark & Steven Bornfeld...
Posted: Wed Jul 02, 2008 2:36 pm
Guest
JimSocal wrote:
Quote:
On Thu, 26 Jun 2008 15:06:52 GMT, Mark & Steven Bornfeld
bornfeldmung at (no spam) dentaltwins.com> wrote:

Richard wrote:
A custom abutment is a part that is machined out of a block of titanium
which fits into the implant and a crown is made over it. Some doctors or
laboratories use them for all of their cases, some use modified stock
abutments. I have never used them. For more info:
http://www.atlantiscomp.com/

JimSocal wrote:
... and when is it necessary to have one?


This looks like an interesting technology, but most custom abutments
are not milled by a CAD-CAM technology--they are custom cast, usually
in gold alloy (there is a titanium understructure that screws into the
implant fixture.
They are generally used when the placement of the implant fixture is
such that it is not possible to place a functional, esthetic crown using
a stock (pre-made) abutment. Of course, occasionally fixtures are
placed such that it's impossible to put a crown or attachment in a good
clinical position. That's why collaboration between the surgeon and
restorative dentist is so important.

Steve

Thank you Richard and Dr. Bornfeld for your answers.

This is what my student dentist told me (I got an email back from her
after your replies; this work was done about a year ago):

"custom abutments are not required, stock abutments could have been
used, but in my experience results are better with custom abutments
especially when multiple implants are used as in your case. Some form
of abutment has to be used otherwise the PFM (crown) can not be
placed, since it is the connector between the implant screw and crown.

I'm not sure why your original treatment plan did not include the
custom abutments, it might have been that at the time of your original
treatment plan the University did not charge for abutments."
-------------------------------------------------------
By the way, if her last comment is the case, then I think the prices
on my treatment plan should be honored.

This is why I am asking the question:
I had a Treatment Plan for 4 implant crowns and it called for 6
implant crowns at $850 each. [2 had not yet been done at the time of
this bill). This is what I agreed to and I was never told anything
different was going to be done or that any expenses were being added.

So when I got my bill, I saw that I was charged $675 for the Implant
crowns, high noble - but also 4 x $650 for "Implant Custom Abutments".

So that is $2600 more than what I was told I'd be charged, and no one
dicussed this with me! (??!!)

(Granted, the PFM's were $175 less each so that offsets some of the
difference, but still that leaves a $1900 difference added.)

So I am in the process of contesting this on the grounds that I was
never told they would be needed.

Would it not be standard practice to tell a patient if an extra $2600
was going to be added to his bill? especially if he has a signed
treatment plan that does not call for custom abutments?

I think at the very least they should compromise with me and charge me
LESS for the custom abutments.

What do you think?

And maybe you can help me out here - if I paid $650 per crown and $675
per custom abutment (remember, this is at a dental school, so I should
get it cheaper - I had to endure many more appt's than necessary for
their lack of competence and many more hours in the chair for the same
reason plus they are learning on me), how much room is there for them
to discount this any further to allow for any money back due to their
having not told me about it?

I'm willing to compromise as I understand it may have just been an
oversight, but still I don't think it's right to expect a person to
pay $1900 more than their treatment plan called for without having
told them.

And finally, what would be an average ballpark price for custom
abutments per crown at a dental office?

Comments? Opinions?


I've done custom abutments where the lab fee is over $600. There
should be some profit margin, but ordinarily I don't think it needs to
be much, as it's basically nuts and bolts. But the materials charges
are high, and the tools required are expensive.
You are asking a question that really is contract law. I'm guessing
that you must have signed some kind of consent or contract. If so, the
fee estimate should be spelled out (with reasonable provisions for
unanticipated changes). IMO the need for abutments should be explained
to the patient, but in my experience some patients remember, and some
don't. I have no idea about the legal issues, so I can't help you there.

Steve

--
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
http://www.dentaltwins.com
Brooklyn, NY
718-258-5001
JimSocal...
Posted: Wed Jul 02, 2008 3:40 pm
Guest
On Wed, 02 Jul 2008 19:36:14 GMT, Mark & Steven Bornfeld
<bornfeldmung at (no spam) dentaltwins.com> wrote:


Quote:
Comments? Opinions?


"I've done custom abutments where the lab fee is over $600. There
should be some profit margin, but ordinarily I don't think it needs to
be much, as it's basically nuts and bolts. But the materials charges
are high, and the tools required are expensive.
You are asking a question that really is contract law. I'm guessing
that you must have signed some kind of consent or contract. If so, the
fee estimate should be spelled out (with reasonable provisions for
unanticipated changes). IMO the need for abutments should be explained
to the patient, but in my experience some patients remember, and some
don't. I have no idea about the legal issues, so I can't help you there.

Steve"

Thanks for your feedback.

It's kind of weird, (almost "flaky" in fact!) but I am almost 100%
certain that even with $12k or surgeries and crowns etc., I never
signed *anything* other than this treatment plan and the treatment
plan is not a "contract" per se (i.e.; no long winded legalese) just a
statement of needing these procedures and the cost with signatures by
me, the student and the prof. If I did sign something it was in the
very beginning, that I had to sign to get admitted to the program. But
never signed anything but this treatment plan after that. In fact I
have every piece of paper they've given me in a notebook and there is
nothing else.

And I am 100% certain that the need for Custom Abutments was never
explained, in fact I was shocked to see them on the bill and thought
they were a mistake.

Now, I find it interesting that the student dentist wrote me back and
said " I'm not sure why your original treatment plan did not include
the custom abutments, it might have been that at the time of your
original treatment plan the University did not charge for abutments."

I find it interesting because it seems to me that it should have been
HER (or at least her professor) who should have told me if there was
any change to my treatment plan, as per custom abutments. But it seems
they just did what they wanted with no concern for cost to me or my
consent.

Also there is this:
I just finished my last 2 crowns (a 2 crown bridge) with the same
school, though a different dept., and they did NOT use custom
abutments and when I asked the prof there about why these custom
abutments might have been used, he said "I have no idea why" as if it
was not standard policy.

I guess I cannot prove they never told me about the change, but then
again, they cannot prove they did (because they did not).

So at the very least we should work out a compromise in which I get
some of the money taken off my bill, I think. Otherwise I guess I'll
take it to Small Claims court.
 
Page 1 of 1       All times are GMT - 5 Hours
The time now is Fri Dec 05, 2008 9:25 am