Main Page | Report this Page
 
   
Science Forum Index  »  Math - Symbolic Forum  »  Leibniz Integral Rule On MathWorld
Page 1 of 1    
Author Message
Guest
Posted: Fri Dec 22, 2006 11:44 pm
Hello everyone,

I'm trying to reproduce the example integral on MathWorld for Leibniz
Integral Rule

http://mathworld.wolfram.com/LeibnizIntegralRule.html

namely,

\phi[\alpha] = \int_0^\pi log[1 - 2 \alpha \cos[x] + \alpha^2 ] dx = 2
\pi log | \alpha |

It appears a little strange that, the LHS and RHS do not match up when
\alpha \to 0, since the former would be int_0^\pi log[1] dx = 0,
whereas the latter would be 2 \pi log[0] = -\infty. Am I missing
something?

I actually got up to

\phi[\alpha] = 2 \pi log | \alpha | + constant

by differentiating w.r.t \alpha, changing variables to t = \tan[x/2],
obtaining an even integrand in t, extending the limits from {0, \infty}
to {-\infty, \infty} and then using contour integration. But I'm unable
to show that the above constant is zero as asserted in MathWorld.

Thanks for the help, and happy holidays!
G. A. Edgar
Posted: Sat Dec 23, 2006 7:42 am
Guest
In article <1166845444.134113.318100@i12g2000cwa.googlegroups.com>,
<wandering.the.cosmos@gmail.com> wrote:

Quote:
Hello everyone,

I'm trying to reproduce the example integral on MathWorld for Leibniz
Integral Rule

http://mathworld.wolfram.com/LeibnizIntegralRule.html

namely,

\phi[\alpha] = \int_0^\pi log[1 - 2 \alpha \cos[x] + \alpha^2 ] dx = 2
\pi log | \alpha |

It appears a little strange that, the LHS and RHS do not match up when
\alpha \to 0,

Note the condition |alpha| > 1 ?? When -1 < alpha < 1, then
the integrand is unbounded, and there are negative values inside the
logarithm.

Quote:
since the former would be int_0^\pi log[1] dx = 0,
whereas the latter would be 2 \pi log[0] = -\infty. Am I missing
something?

I actually got up to

\phi[\alpha] = 2 \pi log | \alpha | + constant

by differentiating w.r.t \alpha, changing variables to t = \tan[x/2],
obtaining an even integrand in t, extending the limits from {0, \infty}
to {-\infty, \infty} and then using contour integration. But I'm unable
to show that the above constant is zero as asserted in MathWorld.

Thanks for the help, and happy holidays!


Take the integrand log(1-2*a*cos(x)+a^2)
Differentiate with respect to a, to get
(-2*cos(x)+2*a)/(1-2*a*cos(x)+a^2)
Integrate that x=0 to Pi to get 2*pi/a, here we must assume a>2.
Integrate with respect to a to get the answer.

As you know, putting a=0 to get the constant doesn't
work. Try letting a -> infinity to do that.
The original integral is asymptotic to 2*Pi*log(a), so
the constant must be zero.

--
G. A. Edgar http://www.math.ohio-state.edu/~edgar/
G. A. Edgar
Posted: Sat Dec 23, 2006 7:46 am
Guest
I wrote:

Quote:
Integrate that x=0 to Pi to get 2*pi/a, here we must assume a>2.

a>1

--
G. A. Edgar http://www.math.ohio-state.edu/~edgar/
Dushan Mitrovich
Posted: Sun Dec 24, 2006 3:09 am
Guest
"G. A. Edgar" <edgar@math.ohio-state.edu.invalid> wrote:
Quote:
In article <1166845444.134113.318100@i12g2000cwa.googlegroups.com>,
wandering.the.cosmos@gmail.com> wrote:

Hello everyone,

I'm trying to reproduce the example integral on MathWorld for Leibniz
Integral Rule

http://mathworld.wolfram.com/LeibnizIntegralRule.html

namely,

\phi[\alpha] = \int_0^\pi log[1 - 2 \alpha \cos[x] + \alpha^2 ] dx = 2
\pi log | \alpha |

It appears a little strange that, the LHS and RHS do not match up when
\alpha \to 0,

Note the condition |alpha| > 1 ?? When -1 < alpha < 1, then the
integrand is unbounded, and there are negative values inside the
logarithm.

But
1 - 2*a*cos(x) + a^2 = 1 - 2*a*cos(x) + a^2*(cos(x)^2 + sin(x)^2)

= (1 - a*cos(x))^2 + (a*sin(x))^2

Quote:
= 0 for all real 'a' and real 'x'

so I don't understand your last statement. Am I missing something?

- Dushan Mitrovich


Quote:
since the former would be int_0^\pi log[1] dx = 0,
whereas the latter would be 2 \pi log[0] = -\infty. Am I missing
something?

I actually got up to

\phi[\alpha] = 2 \pi log | \alpha | + constant

by differentiating w.r.t \alpha, changing variables to t = \tan[x/2],
obtaining an even integrand in t, extending the limits from {0, \infty}
to {-\infty, \infty} and then using contour integration. But I'm unable
to show that the above constant is zero as asserted in MathWorld.

Thanks for the help, and happy holidays!


Take the integrand log(1-2*a*cos(x)+a^2)
Differentiate with respect to a, to get
(-2*cos(x)+2*a)/(1-2*a*cos(x)+a^2)
Integrate that x=0 to Pi to get 2*pi/a, here we must assume a>2.
Integrate with respect to a to get the answer.

As you know, putting a=0 to get the constant doesn't
work. Try letting a -> infinity to do that.
The original integral is asymptotic to 2*Pi*log(a), so
the constant must be zero.

--
G. A. Edgar http://www.math.ohio-state.edu/~edgar/
Vladimir Bondarenko
Posted: Sun Dec 24, 2006 4:13 am
Guest
G. A. Edgar wrote:

[...]

Quote:
As you know, putting a=0 to get the constant doesn't
work. Try letting a -> infinity to do that.
The original integral is asymptotic to 2*Pi*log(a), so
the constant must be zero.

[...]

A typical behavior of a theoretical physicist Wink
CW
Posted: Sun Dec 24, 2006 7:39 pm
Guest
This graph shows the derivative :

plot(piecewise(alpha < 0,2*Pi/(alpha+1),alpha < 1,0,1 <
alpha,2/alpha*Pi),alpha=-4..4,view=[DEFAULT,-4..8],discont=true,thickness=2,color=red);

Chris

wandering.the.cosmos@gmail.com wrote:
Quote:

Hello everyone,

I'm trying to reproduce the example integral on MathWorld for Leibniz
Integral Rule

http://mathworld.wolfram.com/LeibnizIntegralRule.html

namely,

\phi[\alpha] = \int_0^\pi log[1 - 2 \alpha \cos[x] + \alpha^2 ] dx = 2
\pi log | \alpha |

It appears a little strange that, the LHS and RHS do not match up when
\alpha \to 0, since the former would be int_0^\pi log[1] dx = 0,
whereas the latter would be 2 \pi log[0] = -\infty. Am I missing
something?

I actually got up to

\phi[\alpha] = 2 \pi log | \alpha | + constant

by differentiating w.r.t \alpha, changing variables to t = \tan[x/2],
obtaining an even integrand in t, extending the limits from {0, \infty}
to {-\infty, \infty} and then using contour integration. But I'm unable
to show that the above constant is zero as asserted in MathWorld.

Thanks for the help, and happy holidays!
Waldek Hebisch
Posted: Thu Jan 04, 2007 4:05 pm
Guest
G. A. Edgar <edgar@math.ohio-state.edu.invalid> wrote:
Quote:
In article <1166845444.134113.318100@i12g2000cwa.googlegroups.com>,
wandering.the.cosmos@gmail.com> wrote:

Hello everyone,

I'm trying to reproduce the example integral on MathWorld for Leibniz
Integral Rule

http://mathworld.wolfram.com/LeibnizIntegralRule.html

namely,

\phi[\alpha] = \int_0^\pi log[1 - 2 \alpha \cos[x] + \alpha^2 ] dx = 2
\pi log | \alpha |

It appears a little strange that, the LHS and RHS do not match up when
\alpha \to 0,

Note the condition |alpha| > 1 ?? When -1 < alpha < 1, then
the integrand is unbounded, and there are negative values inside the
logarithm.


As Dushan Mitrovich noted the integral is convergent for all real a
(when |a| = 1 there is logarithmic (so integrable) singularity).

Quote:
since the former would be int_0^\pi log[1] dx = 0,
whereas the latter would be 2 \pi log[0] = -\infty. Am I missing
something?

I actually got up to

\phi[\alpha] = 2 \pi log | \alpha | + constant

by differentiating w.r.t \alpha, changing variables to t = \tan[x/2],
obtaining an even integrand in t, extending the limits from {0, \infty}
to {-\infty, \infty} and then using contour integration. But I'm unable
to show that the above constant is zero as asserted in MathWorld.

Thanks for the help, and happy holidays!


Take the integrand log(1-2*a*cos(x)+a^2)
Differentiate with respect to a, to get
(-2*cos(x)+2*a)/(1-2*a*cos(x)+a^2)
Integrate that x=0 to Pi to get 2*pi/a, here we must assume a>2.
Integrate with respect to a to get the answer.

As you know, putting a=0 to get the constant doesn't
work. Try letting a -> infinity to do that.
The original integral is asymptotic to 2*Pi*log(a), so
the constant must be zero.


If |a| < 1, then the integral of (-2*cos(x)+2*a)/(1-2*a*cos(x)+a^2) is
0, so in the interval [-1,1] the value of \phi is constant (and equal to
zero since \phi(0) = 0). Knowing \phi in [-1,1] we can get also
|a| > 1 :

\int_0^\pi log[1 - 2 a \cos[x] + a^2 ] dx =
\int_0^\pi log[a^2] + log[1 - 2/a \cos[x] + 1/a^2 ] dx =
2\pi log[a]

--
Waldek Hebisch
hebisch@math.uni.wroc.pl
Guest
Posted: Fri Feb 16, 2007 5:05 am
On Jan 4, 9:05 pm, Waldek Hebisch <hebi...@math.uni.wroc.pl> wrote:
Quote:

If |a| < 1, then the integral of (-2*cos(x)+2*a)/(1-2*a*cos(x)+a^2) is
0,

Could you explain why the integral is zero for |a|<1?

Thanks!
A N Niel
Posted: Fri Feb 16, 2007 9:26 am
Guest
In article <1171616723.714923.311860@j27g2000cwj.googlegroups.com>,
<wandering.the.cosmos@gmail.com> wrote:

Quote:
On Jan 4, 9:05 pm, Waldek Hebisch <hebi...@math.uni.wroc.pl> wrote:

If |a| < 1, then the integral of (-2*cos(x)+2*a)/(1-2*a*cos(x)+a^2) is
0,

Could you explain why the integral is zero for |a|<1?

Thanks!


Cauchy's integral theorem. The integral of dz/(z-1) around the circle
|z|=a is zero if the pole 1 is outside the circle.
Guest
Posted: Sat Feb 17, 2007 10:34 pm
On Feb 16, 8:26 am, A N Niel <ann...@nym.alias.net.invalid> wrote:
Quote:

Cauchy's integral theorem. The integral of dz/(z-1) around the circle
|z|=a is zero if the pole 1 is outside the circle.

Is there a simple way to see that the integrand is of the form 1/(z-1)
and the contour to take is the circle |z| = a? I've managed to show
that the integral is indeed zero if |a|<1 but I first put t=tan[x/2]
and extended my integral from 0 to infty to -infty to +infty.
 
Page 1 of 1       All times are GMT - 5 Hours
The time now is Wed Oct 08, 2008 6:39 am