Main Page | Report this Page
 
Loading..
   
Science Forum Index  »  Medicine - Dentistry Forum  »  File btoken during root canal
Page 1 of 1    
Author Message
Guest
Posted: Tue Jan 30, 2007 7:12 pm
Ok, I know that it happens, or at least now I do. I went to the
dentist to have a root canal performed. The procedure went fine until
they took an x-ray at the end (before filling it) and found that part
of the file had broken off. I was then told to go to a specialist
which they referred me to. I went and he did a whole new root canal
and removed part of the file. My problem is that I was charged and
extra $245 to have the obstruction removed. Like I said I understand
that stuff like that happens, however I believe it is my dental
offices responsibility to reinburse me for the $245 fee since it was
the dentists doing, not mine. I filed a greivance with the office,
however I'm not sure how good of a chance I have of being reimbersed
so I just wondered if this had happened to anyone else and if there
was any advice out there that would be helpful!!
Thanks,
Cassies mommy
Back to top
JimSocal
Posted: Wed Jan 31, 2007 3:18 am
Guest
On 30 Jan 2007 15:12:33 -0800, Cassiesmommy@gmail.com wrote:

Quote:
Ok, I know that it happens, or at least now I do. I went to the
dentist to have a root canal performed. The procedure went fine until
they took an x-ray at the end (before filling it) and found that part
of the file had broken off. I was then told to go to a specialist
which they referred me to. I went and he did a whole new root canal
and removed part of the file. My problem is that I was charged and
extra $245 to have the obstruction removed. Like I said I understand
that stuff like that happens, however I believe it is my dental
offices responsibility to reinburse me for the $245 fee since it was
the dentists doing, not mine. I filed a greivance with the office,
however I'm not sure how good of a chance I have of being reimbersed
so I just wondered if this had happened to anyone else and if there
was any advice out there that would be helpful!!
Thanks,
Cassies mommy
I agree. It was their doing, not your's, so they should not charge

you. If you live in the U.S. you can threaten them with going to small
claims court.

If they do charge you, I'd suggest writing a formal letter, send it
via registered mail (keep a copy) and let them know that if you have
to pay, they'll have to go to small claims court.

Good luck.
Back to top
Mark & Steven Bornfeld
Posted: Wed Jan 31, 2007 11:31 am
Guest
JimSocal wrote:
Quote:
On 30 Jan 2007 15:12:33 -0800, Cassiesmommy@gmail.com wrote:


Ok, I know that it happens, or at least now I do. I went to the
dentist to have a root canal performed. The procedure went fine until
they took an x-ray at the end (before filling it) and found that part
of the file had broken off. I was then told to go to a specialist
which they referred me to. I went and he did a whole new root canal
and removed part of the file. My problem is that I was charged and
extra $245 to have the obstruction removed. Like I said I understand
that stuff like that happens, however I believe it is my dental
offices responsibility to reinburse me for the $245 fee since it was
the dentists doing, not mine. I filed a greivance with the office,
however I'm not sure how good of a chance I have of being reimbersed
so I just wondered if this had happened to anyone else and if there
was any advice out there that would be helpful!!
Thanks,
Cassies mommy

I agree. It was their doing, not your's, so they should not charge
you. If you live in the U.S. you can threaten them with going to small
claims court.

If they do charge you, I'd suggest writing a formal letter, send it
via registered mail (keep a copy) and let them know that if you have
to pay, they'll have to go to small claims court.

Good luck.


I know it's easy to imagine that this is in fact the case. I also know
you've had your problems personally with dentists. I don't doubt that
you have been treated poorly, and can't rule out the possibility that
you have been treated negligently.
Of course, there MAY have been negligence in the OP's procedure that
contributed to the file breaking. But that will be exceedingly
difficult to demonstrate, and every dentist that does root canals has
instrument failure from time to time. In other words a broken
instrument does NOT equal negligence.
I might add that many dentists would not even mention the broken
instrument, and in many cases it would be difficult to know that it
happened unless the dentist (or another dentist) told the patient about
it. The majority of cases with broken files in fact succeed, and many
without broken files sometimes fail. Please note that I am not
advocating breaking files in canals. I'm just giving you my impression
that from the OP's description, the dentist sounds to me like a stand-up
kinda guy (and believe me, if you read my posts regularly I have no
problem saying so when I think this is NOT the case).
I do get the nagging feeling that part of the money story isn't
here--perhaps the $245 was an insurance copay and not the total fee.
It's unclear who finished the root canal, and exactly what the
endodontist charged the patient for.
Finally, while it may sound callous and inconsiderate to say things
like this DO happen, and it is tempting when things go wrong to want to
blame someone, I can guarantee that even the very best doctors (and
maybe especially the very best doctors, since they are often entrusted
with the most seriously ill patients) have poor results. Insisting that
doctors conduct themselves competently is one thing; assuming a bad
result must be the doctor's fault is quite another thing. Even the
lawyers recognize that for a condition to be actionable, bad results is
not enough. You have to demonstrate negligence (deviation from
generally accepted good practice), damages (medical, financial, etc.)
and proximate cause--that negligent action directly caused the damage to
the patient. We do not have that here, because we would have to
demonstrate that the breaking of the instrument was the result of
negligent use. You're not going to do this.
Since I believe any dentist will understand that many patients in the
OP's position will be angry, I think the OP was totally correct in
bringing this issue up with the dentist. It is quite possible that a
mutually agreeable solution will be found.

Steve

--
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
http://www.dentaltwins.com
Brooklyn, NY
718-258-5001
Back to top
 
Page 1 of 1       All times are GMT - 5 Hours
The time now is Tue Jul 08, 2008 11:27 pm
Science Forum Index

Powered by phpBB & ML | Disclaimer | Ads: Slovak Forum , Golden Retriever Forum



Contact Us