| |
 |
|
|
Science Forum Index » Medicine - Cancer Forum » Cancer Scientist's Dirty Little Secret
Page 1 of 1
|
| Author |
Message |
| E.Nigma |
 Posted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 1:02 pm |
|
|
|
Guest
|
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Renowned Cancer Scientist Was Paid by Chemical Firm for 20 Years
by Sarah Boseley
A world-famous British scientist failed to disclose that he held a
paid consultancy with a chemical company for more than 20 years while
investigating cancer risks in the industry, the Guardian can reveal.
Sir Richard Doll, the celebrated epidemiologist who established that
smoking causes lung cancer, was receiving a consultancy fee of $1,500
a day in the mid-1980s from Monsanto, then a major chemical company
and now better known for its GM crops business.
While he was being paid by Monsanto, Sir Richard wrote to a royal
Australian commission investigating the potential cancer-causing
properties of Agent Orange, made by Monsanto and used by the US in
the Vietnam war. Sir Richard said there was no evidence that the
chemical caused cancer.
Documents seen by the Guardian reveal that Sir Richard was also paid
a #15,000 fee by the Chemical Manufacturers Association and two other
major companies, Dow Chemicals and ICI, for a review that largely
cleared vinyl chloride, used in plastics, of any link with cancers
apart from liver cancer - a conclusion with which the World Health
Organisation disagrees. Sir Richard's review was used by the
manufacturers' trade association to defend the chemical for more than
a decade.
The revelations will dismay scientists and other admirers of Sir
Richard's pioneering work and fuel a rift between the majority who
support his view that the evidence shows cancer is a product of
modern lifestyles and those environmentalists who argue that
chemicals and pollution must be to blame for soaring cancer rates.
Yesterday Sir Richard Peto, the Oxford-based epidemiologist who
worked closely with him, said the allegations came from those who
wanted to damage Sir Richard's reputation for their own reasons. Sir
Richard had always been open about his links with industry and gave
all his fees to Green College, Oxford, the postgraduate institution
he founded, he said.
Professor John Toy, medical director of Cancer Research UK, which
funded much of Sir Richard's work, said times had changed and the
accusations must be put into context. "Richard Doll's lifelong
service to public health has saved millions of lives. His pioneering
work demonstrated the link between smoking and lung cancer and paved
the way towards current efforts to reduce tobacco's death toll," he
said. "In the days he was publishing it was not automatic for
potential conflicts of interest to be declared in scientific papers."
But a Swedish professor who believes that some of Sir Richard's work
has led to the underestimation of the role of chemicals in causing
cancers said that transparency was all-important. "It's OK for any
scientist to be a consultant to anybody, but then this should be
reported in the papers that you publish," said Lennart Hardell of
University Hospital, Orebro.
Sir Richard died last year. Among his papers in the Wellcome
Foundation library archive is a contract he signed with Monsanto.
Dated April 29 1986, it extends for a year the consulting agreement
that began on May 10 1979 and offers improved terms. "During the
one-year period of this extension your consulting fee shall be $1,500
per day," it says.
Monsanto said yesterday it did not know how much work Sir Richard did
for the company, but said he was an expert witness for Solutia, a
chemical business spun off from Monsanto, as recently as 2000.
===
Published on Friday, December 8, 2006 by the Guardian / UK
E.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: PGP Personal Privacy 6.5.3
iQEVAwUBRX2I3tAqdZr/mrO9AQF2mQf+K3ViOALxid6fzR0hHB1kKkHEwGHAFfMN
rbQOwMtmEa1BtrMank8Z+1ZV7meoXNZw3bzXfn83klLdMhNs/cKVuBeBGCy/kFTq
fDJh9M8CJ0rrzAIX5kTVnVj7jTYzhSVC2uej/Q0HohUFYmiqFu2ki5DRbM5008hc
GgOlXy0RglI0BcYkQ+ezoxuG3k1s2HLmUtli0A8Q15bBwqb92X/Ua4iEDwm703Xi
4EVCVj10VlbuYUuGVBbeoosUcrJfzlYeA6mxXsB1hwiT7BL7j3UDsmjZhguiht0r
iRHCse6XQ2yhMq8zJQSEASGLNaQ/oSSS4AtEFWoj11fab6zxanh+Dw==
=taLR
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
This message was posted via one or more anonymous remailing services.
The original sender is unknown. Any address shown in the From header
is unverified. You need a valid hashcash token to post to groups other
than alt.test and alt.anonymous.messages. Visit www.panta-rhei.eu.org
for abuse and hashcash info. |
|
|
| Back to top |
|
| |
|
Page 1 of 1
All times are GMT - 5 Hours
The time now is Wed Oct 08, 2008 4:01 am
|
|