Main Page | Report this Page
 
   
Science Forum Index  »  Medicine - Dentistry Forum  »  Facing a root canal or extraction
Page 3 of 4    Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next
Author Message
Mark & Steven Bornfeld
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2008 10:42 am
Guest
Amatus Cremona wrote:
Quote:
Unfortunately, they're one of only two practices in this area that accept
my insurance--



Danger Will Robinson ! ! ! {Waving arms in air}




Robby the Robot had more, um, gravitas in "Forbidden Planet". Also,
Anne Francis...

Steve

--
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
http://www.dentaltwins.com
Brooklyn, NY
718-258-5001
Dartos
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2008 10:49 am
Guest
Quote:
As I mentioned, it's been a month since my pulpotomy. I think my temp
filling is holding up OK but I'm not sure how long I have before
something MUST be done. I'd love to just call the whole thing off and
go to another practice but I can't afford it.

Welcome to HMO dentistry.

Cost cutting usually leads to compromises in treatment. Of course,
some dentists charge regular fees and still cut corners, but lower
fees almost guarantee it.

On the affordability issue, what will happen if the root canal is
poorly done, and you have to pay a specialist (or other dentist) to
do it over? What if the tooth is lost?

D
Amatus Cremona
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2008 1:02 pm
Guest
Yes

and

Perhaps (often Yes)

--
/

Amatus

/
<electronic_dave@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:924320b8-d760-42cb-ab8a-8dffd8e31dbf@2g2000hsn.googlegroups.com...
On Apr 9, 11:29 am, "Amatus Cremona" <Nic...@sottovocce.com> wrote:
Quote:
Unfortunately, they're one of only two practices in this area that
accept
my insurance--

Danger Will Robinson ! ! ! {Waving arms in air}

You mean, my insurance sucks? (I knew that).
Or the practice must suck if they accept my sucky insurance? Wink
Guest
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2008 1:29 pm
On Apr 9, 3:45 pm, "Amatus Cremona" <Nic...@sottovocce.com> wrote:
Quote:
If we are doing an over-denture abutment tooth RCT with NO rubber
dam,,,,,,,,,,, I am more OCD than normal. My assistant has to hold a pair
of cotton forceps in one hand at all times, and no one is allowed to
distract us. If the patient cannot sit *real* still, we start tying floss
to each file. Rotary files at least don't slip out into the mouth.

If I understand all I've been reading correctly, the purpose of the
dam (along with preventing swallowing or aspiration of instruments) is
to protect the root canals from saliva and also to prevent ingestion
of the chemical(s) that are used to disinfect the root canals. In
cases where a dam cannot be used for whatever reason, how are these
two factors dealt with?

I've found several photos and even a couple of video clips showing a
dam in place and all these examples involve a lower tooth. My
procedure involves my upper right first molar. Does this make any
difference? (I suspect not).

I'm getting the feeling that if they refuse to use a dam without good
reason, I should probably get up and walk out. Would you?

I'm still not totally clear on the reasons why RCT is "better" than
extraction but I suppose that's a topic for another thread. Me, I'd
just as soon have them take the damn thing out and be done with it Smile
Dartos
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2008 2:36 pm
Guest
10-4 good buddy!

On one dental list, it is commonly stated that if there is a
malpractice claim against a dentist that involves a root canal,
and the dentist did not use a rubber dam, it is an automatic
win for the plaintiff.

One aspirated or swallowed file, and life as a dentist has
been forever changed.

D

Amatus Cremona wrote:
Quote:
Unless the front desk person misunderstood and thought the patient wanted a
rubber dam for restorative work.

I agree that a rubber dam should be used whenever possible for RCT. Once in
a great while, you have a tooth which cannot easily accept a dam-clamp and
you do it without the rubber dam, but that is barely one case every 2-3
years. Most teeth that will not hold clamp in place are not good enough to
do RCT on. Sometimes, they are still good enough for over-denture
abutments.
Amatus Cremona
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2008 3:45 pm
Guest
If we are doing an over-denture abutment tooth RCT with NO rubber
dam,,,,,,,,,,, I am more OCD than normal. My assistant has to hold a pair
of cotton forceps in one hand at all times, and no one is allowed to
distract us. If the patient cannot sit *real* still, we start tying floss
to each file. Rotary files at least don't slip out into the mouth.

--
/

Amatus

/
"Dartos" <tuthjockey@myturbonet.com> wrote in message
news:1207771112_79504@news.newsville.com...
Quote:


10-4 good buddy!

On one dental list, it is commonly stated that if there is a
malpractice claim against a dentist that involves a root canal,
and the dentist did not use a rubber dam, it is an automatic
win for the plaintiff.

One aspirated or swallowed file, and life as a dentist has
been forever changed.

D

Amatus Cremona wrote:
Unless the front desk person misunderstood and thought the patient wanted
a rubber dam for restorative work.

I agree that a rubber dam should be used whenever possible for RCT. Once
in a great while, you have a tooth which cannot easily accept a dam-clamp
and you do it without the rubber dam, but that is barely one case every
2-3 years. Most teeth that will not hold clamp in place are not good
enough to do RCT on. Sometimes, they are still good enough for
over-denture abutments.

Mark & Steven Bornfeld
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2008 6:46 pm
Guest
electronic_dave@hotmail.com wrote:
Quote:
On Apr 9, 3:45 pm, "Amatus Cremona" <Nic...@sottovocce.com> wrote:
If we are doing an over-denture abutment tooth RCT with NO rubber
dam,,,,,,,,,,, I am more OCD than normal. My assistant has to hold a pair
of cotton forceps in one hand at all times, and no one is allowed to
distract us. If the patient cannot sit *real* still, we start tying floss
to each file. Rotary files at least don't slip out into the mouth.

If I understand all I've been reading correctly, the purpose of the
dam (along with preventing swallowing or aspiration of instruments) is
to protect the root canals from saliva and also to prevent ingestion
of the chemical(s) that are used to disinfect the root canals. In
cases where a dam cannot be used for whatever reason, how are these
two factors dealt with?

I've found several photos and even a couple of video clips showing a
dam in place and all these examples involve a lower tooth. My
procedure involves my upper right first molar. Does this make any
difference? (I suspect not).

Isolation of the upper teeth is easier, since any saliva flows down.
In those instances where you cannot get a dam to stay (very rare), you
pack the mouth with a lot of gauze, and tie all your instruments.

Quote:

I'm getting the feeling that if they refuse to use a dam without good
reason, I should probably get up and walk out. Would you?

Probably.
Quote:

I'm still not totally clear on the reasons why RCT is "better" than
extraction but I suppose that's a topic for another thread. Me, I'd
just as soon have them take the damn thing out and be done with it Smile


There is no one answer. You have to look at what kind of shape the
tooth is in--both structurally and periodontally. You're putting a lot
of effort into saving the tooth and the effort and/or money isn't worth
it if there isn't a reasonable expectation of long-term success--that
is, you save the tooth for a long time. The decision may also depend
somewhat on the condition of the other teeth in the mouth.
Since cash is a problem, I assume there is no consideration for a
bridge or implant-retained prosthesis.
Your circumstances may change down the road, and you may be able to
afford a fancy prosthesis, so this should be weighed against the chance
of success with a root canal and crown.
If you can't get the crown done, and you have no reasonable expectation
of being able to do the crown within a year or so, this makes the case
for doing a root canal much weaker IMO.

Steve
Quote:



--
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
http://www.dentaltwins.com
Brooklyn, NY
718-258-5001
Guest
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2008 8:26 pm
On Wed, 9 Apr 2008 07:03:14 -0700 (PDT), electronic_dave@hotmail.com
wrote:

Quote:
Hmmm... I've been reading up on the procedure and one consensus I seem
to be finding around the web is that a rubber dam must be used for
safety. A dam was not used for my pulpotomy, and I called the office
to ask if one would be used for my root canal and was told "most of
our dentists don't use them, but *maybe* your dentist will use one if
you request it." (I don't think he was in the office when I called,
otherwise it would've made sense just to ask HIM, right?). Anyway, the
woman to whom I spoke reacted in a way that indicated she thought it
odd that I was even asking about it. Yikes... Should I *insist* on the
dam or no deal?


Yep, rubber dam is considered standard of care.

Endodontists have said that if the tooth cannot
be isolated with a rubber dam, it should be extracted.

Now to include full disclosure many many RCTs have been
sucessfully done without a rubber dam in the past and perhaps
even now.

If it were my tooth --> Rubber dam is mandatory.

You can learn more about endodontics here: www.aae.org
Guest
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2008 8:28 pm
On Wed, 9 Apr 2008 07:51:30 -0700 (PDT), electronic_dave@hotmail.com
wrote:

Quote:
Unfortunately, they're one of only two practices in this
area that accept my insurance--


HMO ?
Guest
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2008 8:29 pm
On Wed, 9 Apr 2008 08:51:20 -0700 (PDT), electronic_dave@hotmail.com
wrote:

Quote:
On Apr 9, 11:49 am, Dartos <tuthjoc...@myturbonet.com> wrote:
As I mentioned, it's been a month since my pulpotomy. I think my temp
filling is holding up OK but I'm not sure how long I have before
something MUST be done. I'd love to just call the whole thing off and
go to another practice but I can't afford it.

Welcome to HMO dentistry.

Cost cutting usually leads to compromises in treatment.  Of course,
some dentists charge regular fees and still cut corners, but lower
fees almost guarantee it.

On the affordability issue, what will happen if the root canal is
poorly done, and you have to pay a specialist (or other dentist) to
do it over?  What if the tooth is lost?

D

I take your point, but I don't have seveal hundred to a thousand bucks
or more hanging out in the bank. I barely have enough for gas and
groceries once the bills are paid. I'm not looking for sympathy, I'm
just telling you this by way of explaining why I feel like I don't
have many options as far as choosing where and by whom the procedure
is to be done.

yeah, HMOs are great, all right Sad


Is there a dental school near you ?
Guest
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2008 8:32 pm
On Wed, 09 Apr 2008 20:45:14 GMT, "Amatus Cremona"
<Nicola@sottovocce.com> wrote:

Quote:
If we are doing an over-denture abutment tooth RCT with NO rubber
dam,,,,,,,,,,, I am more OCD than normal. My assistant has to hold a pair
of cotton forceps in one hand at all times, and no one is allowed to
distract us. If the patient cannot sit *real* still, we start tying floss
to each file. Rotary files at least don't slip out into the mouth.


Then do what endo buddy and me do...

You ain't gonna like it though, *clamp the bone* !
It will heal just fine, try to stay in the attached tissue.

Afterall this is an OD abutment right ?
Or would that be an OCD abutment <vbseg>
Guest
Posted: Wed Apr 09, 2008 8:37 pm
On Wed, 9 Apr 2008 16:29:13 -0700 (PDT), electronic_dave@hotmail.com
wrote:

Quote:
On Apr 9, 3:45 pm, "Amatus Cremona" <Nic...@sottovocce.com> wrote:
If we are doing an over-denture abutment tooth RCT with NO rubber
dam,,,,,,,,,,, I am more OCD than normal. My assistant has to hold a pair
of cotton forceps in one hand at all times, and no one is allowed to
distract us. If the patient cannot sit *real* still, we start tying floss
to each file. Rotary files at least don't slip out into the mouth.

If I understand all I've been reading correctly, the purpose of the
dam (along with preventing swallowing or aspiration of instruments) is
to protect the root canals from saliva and also to prevent ingestion
of the chemical(s) that are used to disinfect the root canals. In
cases where a dam cannot be used for whatever reason, how are these
two factors dealt with?

Probable extraction.

Quote:

I've found several photos and even a couple of video clips showing a
dam in place and all these examples involve a lower tooth. My
procedure involves my upper right first molar. Does this make any
difference? (I suspect not).

No. Little to no difference.
Isolating the tooth is the goal. It's just easier to take pictures
of lowers. When photographing upper the patient must stand
on their head.

Quote:

I'm getting the feeling that if they refuse to use a dam without good
reason, I should probably get up and walk out. Would you?

I would.
Quote:

I'm still not totally clear on the reasons why RCT is "better" than
extraction but I suppose that's a topic for another thread. Me, I'd
just as soon have them take the damn thing out and be done with it Smile


Bornfeld answered this question, and I agree with him but would
problably shorten the time between RCT and crown to 6 weeks.
Guest
Posted: Thu Apr 10, 2008 4:50 am
Now here's another "what if?"

Suppose the patient has trouble breathing through his nose. What then?
Mark & Steven Bornfeld
Posted: Thu Apr 10, 2008 9:59 am
Guest
electronic_dave@hotmail.com wrote:
Quote:
Now here's another "what if?"

Suppose the patient has trouble breathing through his nose. What then?



It is possible to make a hole in a non-critical area of the rubber dam
that will still allow protection of the working area.

Steve

--
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
http://www.dentaltwins.com
Brooklyn, NY
718-258-5001
Guest
Posted: Thu Apr 10, 2008 12:33 pm
On Thu, 10 Apr 2008 14:59:29 GMT, Mark & Steven Bornfeld
<bornfeldmung@dentaltwins.com> wrote:

Quote:
electronic_dave@hotmail.com wrote:
Now here's another "what if?"

Suppose the patient has trouble breathing through his nose. What then?



It is possible to make a hole in a non-critical area of the rubber dam
that will still allow protection of the working area.

Steve


Certainly less drastic than a trach !
 
Page 3 of 4    Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next   All times are GMT - 5 Hours
The time now is Fri Jul 25, 2008 7:43 pm