Main Page | Report this Page
 
   
Hobby Forum Index  »  Motorcycles  »  Aerodynamics...
Page 1 of 2    Goto page 1, 2  Next
Author Message
Bob Throllop...
Posted: Mon Jun 30, 2008 7:29 pm
Guest
I've been wondering how much difference streamlined fairings make to a
cycle's gas mileage. Does anyone have any figures? And in
particular, would putting a windshield on my otherwise naked 650 make
any difference at all?
S'mee...
Posted: Tue Jul 01, 2008 6:07 pm
Guest
On Jul 1, 5:35 am, "Vito" <v... at (no spam) xxcrosslink.net> wrote:
Quote:
"Bob Throllop" <bobthrol... at (no spam) brandx.net> wrote> I've been wondering how much difference streamlined fairings make to a
cycle's gas mileage.  Does anyone have any figures?  And in
particular, would putting a windshield on my otherwise naked 650 make
any difference at all?

Fairings do a lot at racing speeds (over 100 mph) but don't expect any
measurable improvement in gas mileage at typical street speeds. Windshields
are almost as streamlined as barn doors and may actually reduce mileage on
70 mph roads.  Their main advantage on a street bike in weather and insect
protection.

Except for the stuff that gets entrained and beats your helmet on the
sides. Your face also if you are one of the many nimrods that wear
anything but a FF helmet. That's my expierence anyway.
--
Keith
S'mee...
Posted: Tue Jul 01, 2008 6:13 pm
Guest
On Jul 1, 8:53 am, Outback Jon <team... at (no spam) ver.no.sp.am.izon.net> wrote:

Quote:
Something along the lines of what Craig Vetter designs would help...
But they are a bit extreme....

http://www.craigvetter.com/

I've seen what he does to a GL1000. No thankyou very much...it's ugly
and embarassing. I can do one or the other but not both at the same
time. <shrug> Honda hasn't done much better with the GL series, the
latest being the ugliest imnsho. I stick to naked bikes tyvm, cross
winds aren't a problem, just stick out a knee.
--
Keith
Timberwoof...
Posted: Tue Jul 01, 2008 11:24 pm
Guest
In article
<0944e010-19dd-4619-876f-c775271a5021 at (no spam) z32g2000prh.googlegroups.com>,
"S'mee" <stevenkeith2 at (no spam) hotmail.com> wrote:

Quote:
On Jul 1, 8:53 am, Outback Jon <team... at (no spam) ver.no.sp.am.izon.net> wrote:

Something along the lines of what Craig Vetter designs would help...
But they are a bit extreme....

http://www.craigvetter.com/

I've seen what he does to a GL1000. No thankyou very much...it's ugly
and embarassing. I can do one or the other but not both at the same
time. <shrug> Honda hasn't done much better with the GL series, the
latest being the ugliest imnsho. I stick to naked bikes tyvm, cross
winds aren't a problem, just stick out a knee.

I looked at the web site. I liked the name of the "Liberator" fairing
for Harley Davidsons. The name reminds me of a WWII bomber. The fairing,
however, reminds me of a WWII bomber.

--
Timberwoof <me at timberwoof dot com>
faq: http://www.timberwoof.com/motorcycle/faq.shtml
Ten Steps to Fascism: http://www.guardian.co.uk/usa/story/0,,2064157,00.html
Outback Jon...
Posted: Tue Jul 01, 2008 11:54 pm
Guest
Timberwoof wrote:
Quote:
In article
0944e010-19dd-4619-876f-c775271a5021 at (no spam) z32g2000prh.googlegroups.com>,
"S'mee" <stevenkeith2 at (no spam) hotmail.com> wrote:

On Jul 1, 8:53 am, Outback Jon <team... at (no spam) ver.no.sp.am.izon.net> wrote:

Something along the lines of what Craig Vetter designs would help...
But they are a bit extreme....

http://www.craigvetter.com/
I've seen what he does to a GL1000. No thankyou very much...it's ugly
and embarassing. I can do one or the other but not both at the same
time. <shrug> Honda hasn't done much better with the GL series, the
latest being the ugliest imnsho. I stick to naked bikes tyvm, cross
winds aren't a problem, just stick out a knee.

I looked at the web site. I liked the name of the "Liberator" fairing
for Harley Davidsons. The name reminds me of a WWII bomber. The fairing,
however, reminds me of a WWII bomber.


Being that he named it after the bomber, that kind of makes sense.

Although, I think most WWII bombers were far more streamlined than that
fairing was...

--
"Outback" Jon - KC2BNE
outback_jon at (no spam) ver.no.sp.am.izon.net
AMD Opteron 165 ( at (no spam) 2.5) and 6.1 GHz of other AMD power...
http://folding.stanford.edu - got folding? Team 53560

2006 ZG1000A Concours "Blueline" COG# 7385 CDA# 0157
Classic Rider...
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 1:24 am
Guest
On Tue, 1 Jul 2008 07:35:54 -0400, "Vito" <vito at (no spam) xxcrosslink.net>
wrote:

Quote:
"Bob Throllop" <bobthrollop at (no spam) brandx.net> wrote
I've been wondering how much difference streamlined fairings make to a
cycle's gas mileage. Does anyone have any figures? And in
particular, would putting a windshield on my otherwise naked 650 make
any difference at all?

Fairings do a lot at racing speeds (over 100 mph) but don't expect any
measurable improvement in gas mileage at typical street speeds. Windshields
are almost as streamlined as barn doors and may actually reduce mileage on
70 mph roads. Their main advantage on a street bike in weather and insect
protection.

Early in the 50s full motorcycle streamlining was banned. The speeds
were exceeding 175 mph on machines of pitiful power compared to
today's outputs.

A fully streamline motorcycle can achieve 100mph with only 5hp. Since
people in general have little to no understanding of what constitutes
power, and since so many of the "ratings" are essentially created in
the minds of an ad agency, the only real measures of power are how
fast a machine moves.

Windshields on motorcycles have to be carefully designs. A lot of the
otherwise acceptably good handling motorcycles can become dangerous
with a badly designed or badly installed windshield.

BMW (of course) was the first manufacturer to provide a fairing as
part of the motorcycle, which was a trend that should have started
much sooner.

A Formula 1 car has a CD (coefficient of drag) of about 4. A modern
high mileage car, the Toyota Prius is the best of all automobiles at
..25. A typical motorcycle is up around 2.0.

This means simply that most of the horsepower is used to push air
around. The drag effect is not very great until speeds exceed 48 mph,
which is where almost every vehicle made today gets it's best fuel
economy.

========================
Classic Rider
www.2wheelclassics.com
========================
The Older Gentleman...
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 1:30 am
Guest
Classic Rider <ClassicRider at (no spam) 2wheelclassics.com> wrote:

Quote:
BMW (of course) was the first manufacturer to provide a fairing as
part of the motorcycle

Wrong *Again*. Think Ariel Leader. Think Vincent Black Prince.

You know nothing, fuckwit.


--
BMW K1100LT Ducati 750SS Yamaha XT600E Honda CB400F
chateau dot murray at idnet dot com
"What you're proposing to do will involve a lot of time
and hassle for no tangible benefit."
Classic Rider...
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 1:32 am
Guest
On Mon, 11 Aug 2008 08:31:01 +0200, marc.gerges at (no spam) gmail.com (Marc
Gerges) wrote:

Quote:
Classic Rider <ClassicRider at (no spam) 2wheelclassics.com> wrote:

Does anyone have any figures?

On a fully streamlined motorcycle, only 5hp is needed to reach and
sustain 100mph. On an unstreamlined motorcycle this rises to about
42hp.

What would be your definition of fully streamlined?

Something like the NSU world record setter that was run at Bonneville.
http://www.jockeyjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/10/nsu1.jpg

or:
http://www.eurospares.com/graphics/nsu001.jpg

There are some student engineering streamliners which are claiming
upwards of 1450 miles per gallon which look a lot like this.


Quote:
Assuming a cW of round 0,7 and a frontal area A of around 0,6 for the
naked bike needing 42hp to sustain 100 mph, plugging those into
F=0.5*rho*cW*A*v^2 results in an expected cW of 0.08 for the fully
streamlined bike requiring 5hp to sustain 100 mph.

Not to say that's impossible, such vehicles exist. Here's one:

http://www.paccar.ethz.ch/pictures/pac_car_II_miscellaneous/15?hires

Since the 1/2 hp Human Bicycle rider has a current world record of 152
miles per hour behind a wind break, and only about 80 or so without
it, the efficiency of steamlining can easily be inferred.


Quote:
You may notice missing similarity to this:

http://www.motorcycledaily.com/haya.jpg

This is the type of fairing that was banned in racing in the 50s due
to too many fatal accidents. I'm surprised they don't limit engine
sizes at 500 and allow REAL streamlining again.
http://home.cogeco.ca/~rwbaxter/nsu-spor.gif

Formula 1 is going to hybrid drives and bio fuels very soon.
Motorcycles are under attack as being inefficient and unnecessary. So
the FIA should take steps to address this PR problem ASAP.
========================
Classic Rider
www.2wheelclassics.com
========================
Classic Rider...
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 1:34 am
Guest
On Mon, 11 Aug 2008 10:18:13 -0600, "Bob Myers"
<nospamplease at (no spam) address.invalid> wrote:

Quote:

"Marc Gerges" <marc.gerges at (no spam) gmail.com> wrote in message
news:5u25n5-fu1.ln1 at (no spam) pascal.gerges.lu...
Classic Rider <ClassicRider at (no spam) 2wheelclassics.com> wrote:

Does anyone have any figures?

On a fully streamlined motorcycle, only 5hp is needed to reach and
sustain 100mph. On an unstreamlined motorcycle this rises to about
42hp.

What would be your definition of fully streamlined?

Why, a cD of zero, of course...Wink

A CD of Zero would be air with no movement. Perhaps a Hurricane has a
CD of Zero. But at 156 mph (which was what Andrew was blowing at when
I was in it) you can't do much but lay flat on the ground and hope not
to be impailed by flying hay.

The NSU I believe is down around .10. An ultimate streamlined car
which was shown at the 1970 World's Fair in Knoxville was listed as
reach .12.
========================
Classic Rider
www.2wheelclassics.com
========================
Classic Rider...
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 1:46 am
Guest
On Mon, 11 Aug 2008 08:17:00 +0100, totallydeadmailbox at (no spam) yahoo.co.uk
(The Older Gentleman) wrote:

Quote:
Classic Rider <ClassicRider at (no spam) 2wheelclassics.com> wrote:


The difference is incredible. When fully streamlined motorcycles
starting reach speeds of 180 mph in Grand Prix racing they were
banned. Now only half fairings are allowed to help keep the speeds
down.

Christ, you talk as much crap as Krusty. The 'dustbin' full enclosures
that you're taslking about were banned because of their deadly
aerodynamic effects in sidewinds.

Oddly I've heard that no where but here. What I heard in 1959 was
that they were banned because the speeds were going so high that
riders were dying. Back then there were trees lining race tracks.

In the Hemminway context, there is only one real motorcycle race, the
Isle of Man TT. Curiously it's also where the first motorcycle crash
helmets were worn. They still have constant fatalities there.

Since there are no dustbin fairings today, I think perhaps the high
speed and poor brakes and chassis of that day were responsible, not a
supoosed susceptibility to cross winds.

Quote:
Does anyone have any figures?

On a fully streamlined motorcycle, only 5hp is needed to reach and
sustain 100mph.

I really, really doubt this, but am happy to be enlightened. Which
bikes, where, when?

This is a psychics answer. That's all that's needed. The 12 hp
Kreidler 50cc could easily exceed 100mph on a half fairing. So that
tends to support a full streamliner doing 100mph.

Most 5hp steamlinersa are four wheeled. It's hard to have that cut
out in the shell for a rider to put his feet down without losing
steamling. A few have fold down skids since the feet cannot be used.

Quote:
On an unstreamlined motorcycle this rises to about
42hp.

Utter bollocks again. We've done this before. It's about 30bhp.

Nonsense. The first motorcycles to reach 100mph were 42 hp and
higher. I challenge you to show a 30hp motorcycle that was not
streamlined in any way that can reach 100mph unless of course you
throw it off a cliff.

Quote:
The 8hp Volkswagen 1 liter car, which is two passenger and weighs
about 600 lbs. reaches about 85mph. It also burns diesel fuel at the
rate of about 265 miles per gallon. When arrives in 2010-2012 it will
achieve only about 150mpg due to cost savings.

No Googling throws this up.

Of course it does.
http://www.google.com/search?q=1+liter+volkswagen&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a

I first saw it in a Popular Science magazine article.

Quote:
Any more details? Because I seriously doubt
an 8bhp car weighing a quarter of a ton will do 85mph and 265mpg

Try this:
http://www.treehugger.com/files/2008/07/vw-282-mpg-1-one-liter-car-production-2010.php

I don't know where they got the 285 miles per gallon figures. It's CD
is .16 in this article. It won't be carbon fiber and won't achieve 1
liter as the prototype did when in production.

It isn't the only super high mpg car. Opel (a General Motors Company)
is reading a 1.5 liter car also. The VW 1 liter when produced will
burn 1.5 liter or more.

Quote:
Honda's 5hp Super Cut (now havin sold over 60,000,000 units) has a
steady state fuel consumptio rate of 315 mpg at about 36mph.

This is yet more nonsense. The C50 (aka Super Cub) will do well over
100mpg, but over 300 is pure fantasy. Top whack of a C50 stepthru is
about 40mph+, so 36 is going quite fast.

There is one for sale right now that the owner says he gets over 140
mpg with. You should LEARN to read for comprehension.

If you did you'd realize your mistake. The 315 mpg is the ACTUAL fuel
consumption of the engine at 36mph.

My VW Diesl has an ACTUAL steady state consumption at that speed of
more than 85mpg.

Quote:

(PS: I've ridden quite a few)

Where do you get this shit from?

From the REAL engineering sources. I'm sorry you don't understand
basic English. Do I have to speak to you like a 6 year old and
explain what 36mph and 315 mpg means?
========================
Classic Rider
www.2wheelclassics.com
========================
Classic Rider...
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 1:49 am
Guest
On Mon, 11 Aug 2008 14:40:34 +0100, totallydeadmailbox at (no spam) yahoo.co.uk
(The Older Gentleman) wrote:

Quote:
Vito <vito at (no spam) xxcrosslink.net> wrote:

Once truth is lost the ignorant can invent the
silliest reasons for things.

Very true. Ignorance is rife. It's funny that people with experience
are less ignorant.
========================
Classic Rider
www.2wheelclassics.com
========================
Classic Rider...
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 1:52 am
Guest
On Mon, 11 Aug 2008 17:21:38 +0100, totallydeadmailbox at (no spam) yahoo.co.uk
(The Older Gentleman) wrote:

Quote:
Bob Myers <nospamplease at (no spam) address.invalid> wrote:

"The Older Gentleman" <totallydeadmailbox at (no spam) yahoo.co.uk> wrote in message
news:1ili153.cbtx6sjmpjelN%totallydeadmailbox at (no spam) yahoo.co.uk...

The 8hp Volkswagen 1 liter car, which is two passenger and weighs
about 600 lbs. reaches about 85mph. It also burns diesel fuel at the
rate of about 265 miles per gallon. When arrives in 2010-2012 it will
achieve only about 150mpg due to cost savings.

No Googling throws this up. Any more details? Because I seriously doubt
an 8bhp car weighing a quarter of a ton will do 85mph and 265mpg


First, locate a high, high cliff....

Tom Clancy was asked the same thing, but a Senate Investigation
Committee. I have always considered Clancy to be uninformed and his
writing to be unskilled and jeuvenile, (I'd love to have his $8
million advances though). His answer was the same as I gave earlier
to this same question.

Popular Science, etc. etc. etc. I went a bit further and also used
Janes Military information and direct interviews, as I do with all
subjects.

How stuipd is a person who fails to type in a google search window VW
1 liter and then claims not to have found anything???
========================
Classic Rider
www.2wheelclassics.com
========================
Classic Rider...
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 1:52 am
Guest
On Mon, 11 Aug 2008 11:17:55 -0600, "Bob Myers"
<nospamplease at (no spam) address.invalid> wrote:

Quote:
As far as I know, pearls ALWAYS come from a bit of
debris irritating a sort of mollusk that lives in brackish water...

So you're saying the Pacific Ocean is Brackish water?
========================
Classic Rider
www.2wheelclassics.com
========================
Classic Rider...
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 1:53 am
Guest
On Mon, 11 Aug 2008 13:42:59 -0700 (PDT), "S'mee"
<stevenkeith2 at (no spam) hotmail.com> wrote:

Quote:
I didn't know you were an invertibrate. Huh, learn something
everday...a motorcycle riding mollusk, only on reeky I guess.

The Octopus is a very intelligent mollusk. Smarter, obviously than
someone who cannot use google to find the VW 1 liter.
========================
Classic Rider
www.2wheelclassics.com
========================
S'mee...
Posted: Fri Aug 22, 2008 8:20 pm
Guest
On Aug 22, 3:18 pm, Turby <turbosur... at (no spam) beach.comber> wrote:
Quote:
On Fri, 22 Aug 2008 14:06:34 -0700 (PDT), "S'mee"





stevenkei... at (no spam) hotmail.com> wrote:
On Aug 22, 2:27 pm, Turby <turbosur... at (no spam) beach.comber> wrote:
On Fri, 22 Aug 2008 12:58:07 -0700 (PDT), "S'mee"

stevenkei... at (no spam) hotmail.com> wrote:
LOL who the hell drives 45mph on the highway except for the stoned and
the geriatric. Oh and dumbass like the converters of cars like you
mention. Show me 100mpg with a full sized car/pickup/semi-trailer then
I'll be interested in it. Interested in how to adapt teh technology to
a motorcycle.

I'm still waiting for the production Bulldog. And hoping it'll be
something less than the announced $18k.
A real 105mpg at (no spam) 45mph on a machine that spends a lot of time at that
speed. (Who wants to spend all day on an interstate, anyway?):http://www.dieselmotorcycles.com/models.htm

I dunno on most of the dirt roads I've driven on over the years I
rarely went below 60mph in daylight and that is on a street bike

630 miles on 6 gal of biodiesel, which costs ~$1/gal.
San Diego to Reno on one tank of gas and $6. Sounds good to me.

Yebbut there is a fly in the ointment. The Bulldog is indefinately
delayed due to military purchases and an apparently lack of ability to
expand production capability...but that is just speculation on my
part.

Yeah. OTOH, if the Iraq excursion ends, mebbe...

Hey we can hope can't we? I wouldn't mind having one, though where I
can get JP8 instead of Diesel 1 or 2 I'm not sure. It's one of those
"same but different" things iirc.
--
Keith
 
Page 1 of 2    Goto page 1, 2  Next   All times are GMT - 5 Hours
The time now is Mon Dec 01, 2008 10:08 pm